Quote from review of Karim Rashids book Digipop

Jony Ive now synonymous with every kind of industrial design ever – official

Off topic on 30 July 2009

Image courtesy of Firebox.com

Image courtesy of Firebox.com

The Guardian blogs Firebox’s Power Plant Growing Machine, noting its ‘obligatory iPod-style casing’.

What the heck is iPod-like about this? The iMac G5 may have been lurking in somebody’s subconscious, but that would be only slightly more apposite. This kind of feminised domestic white goods styling is too ubiquitous to attribute, though Philips Design under Stefano Marzano would be a good start. My Bosch kettle looks like it. The green accent is very 2001 (the year, not the movie) but in no way reminiscent of Apple. Neither Jonathan Ive nor his predecessors (chiefly Hartmut Esslinger) would have touched the cheap, soft, shiny white finish with a bargepole. Ross Lovegrove might be a tenuous link, but I’m clutching at straws.

If ‘iPod-style’ (or ‘Apple-like’, or ‘Ive-ish’) has become the new ‘designer’ – a lazy adjective signifying something overpriced, self-indulgent and appealing more in form than function – it’s a poor reward for Apple, which has developed a very particular kind of design language closely integrated with world-leading functionality and usability. What’s notable here is that aping Apple is not obligatory. The success of the iPod has encouraged other manufacturers to invest in design, yet this hasn’t resulted in sameyness. A good thing easily smooshed by lazy writing.

Leave a comment...

Previous post: Joy as online font issues finally resolved (not)

Next post: If the solution to illegal downloading is ‘delivering fantastic legal services’, are all those tanks on lawns just delivery vehicles?